Substance use disorder (SUD) includes dependence syndromes and harmful use of illicit drugs and alcohol. SUD is often complicated by a repetitive pattern of abstinence-reinstatement, and psychiatric comorbidities. The personality traits of people with SUD may also be factors contributing to continuous use of substances. Taken together, it is plausible that SUD reflects a complex interplay between substance use, dependence features, clinical symptoms and personality traits. The relationship between substance use and clinical symptoms can be directional in nature. For instance, drug-induced or withdrawal induced clinical symptoms are well recognized. On the other hand, some theorists suggested that clinical patients may use substances as a way of “self-medication”. Such complex relationship between SUD features and symptoms and personality is best to be examined using network analysis. However, relatively few research has examined this area.
To address this issue, Dr. Raymond Chan from Neuropsychology and Applied Cognitive Neuroscience Laboratory, CAS Key Laboratory of Mental Health and his collaborators at the University of Hong Kong (HKU) (Dr. Simon Lui) and Castle Peak Hospital (CPH) (Drs. J Poon and Lam Ming) recruited 391 treatment-seeking SUD patients, and measured substance use, dependence features, clinical symptoms and personality traits using well validated scales. Network analysis was applied to construct regularized partial correlation network and to estimate centrality indices such as strength, closeness, betweenness, and Expected Influence. Moreover, the relative importance of each node was estimated, with substance use and severity of dependence features as the dependent variables.
The results showed a high interconnected regularized partial correlation network. The predictability index suggested that the regularized partial correlation network was “self-sustaining”. Moreover, neuroticism, a personality trait, showed highest closeness index. Depressive symptoms, anxiety symptoms and ‘general’ symptoms in the Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale showed highest expected influence. Regarding relative importance analysis results, the depressive symptoms, anxiety symptoms and ‘general’ symptoms significantly determined the variance of drug use and dependence severity.
Taken together, depressive and anxiety symptoms appeared to be possible intervention target to break the self-sustaining system of SUD. Dr. Chan and his key collaborators at HKU and CPH are planning to conduct follow-up assessments on this cohort, and investigate the temporal stability of the regularized partial correlation network, and to include more refined measures on reward-learning to see if cognitive dysfunctions as such could also be useful intervention targets.
Dr. Johannes Poon from Castle Peak Hospital and Miss Huixin Hu from Institute of Psychology were the co-first authors, while Drs. Raymond Chan and Simon Lui were co-correspondence authors of this study. This study was supported by the CAS Key Laboratory of Mental Health, Institute of Psychology.
This study has been published online in International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction since Dec 1, 2022.
- Poon JYK#, Hu HX#, Lam M, Lui SSY*, Chan RCK* (2022). The interplay between addictive behaviour and psychopathology and personality in substance use disorder: A network analysis in treatment-seeking patients with alcohol and drug use. International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction.
Institute of Psychology
Chinese Academy of Sciences
Beijing 100101, China.